I've been thinking a bunch recently about my cousin Mike. You probably don't know him.
He should be 40 years old, now.
Did I say, should be? Yeah, I did. Even 12 years on, thinking about him like that doesn't get easier.
In my memory, he's 13 years old. We're sitting in my bedroom, playing video games.
He looks up at me and says, "Let's write a book!"
I don't remember looking at him like he was totally crazy, but my memory is unreliable on the best of days. I did say something to the effect of, "About what?"
He proceeded, over the course of a couple hours, to tell me the whole outline of this story he wanted to tell, along with all the characters, complete with names and detailed backgrounds, and dictated the first chapter to me. It was about pirates, buried treasure, treasure maps, booby traps, and all the things that 13-year-old boys would want to read about.
Mike's interest in the project didn't last long (about an hour and a half), but I pecked away at it for a couple years, from time to time, and showed chapters to Mike, and he'd get excited about it all over again. Eventually, I got distracted, and the half-finished story fell by the wayside.
When Mike died, I took out the old trapper keeper (yes!) that held the notebook in which we'd hand-written the first few chapters of our book. I read it again. I cringed a lot. And I thought, why not finish this?
I took a few stabs at it over the next decade, but it still didn't feel write.
Recently, I took another shot, and feel better about this story now than I have since that first night, when 14-year-old Dave and 13-year-old Mike scribbled down a bunch of ideas in a notebook.
Maybe it still sucks, but it at least sucks in ways that Mike would have loved. It's still full of pirates, ghosts, curses, and fun stuff like that.
I've decided, just for fun, and because this is what the internet is made for, to throw the first chapter out there. If you like it, at my current pace I should finish it shortly before my kids go to college. I should say, a lot of this first chapter is true. A lot of it isn't. I won't tell you which is which. The rest of the book is totally fictitious, but this chapter, it had to be rooted in what I remembered. So here it is. (For brevity, I've omitted the prologue.)
We never had a title for our book. These days, I'm calling it, Pieces of Eight.
Chapter 1:
I should begin this account by apologizing for the liberties
that I have taken with the true and verifiable facts to be found within. But narratives of this sort are by necessity
fraught with dangers for veracity and circumstance, which must be sacrificed
for the sake of making it readable. Plus
there is the distorting lens of time, and the inequities of memory, for the
following events occurred in a world very different from that in which we find
ourselves today: the internet was still young and considered by many a sound
investment, phones still made phone calls, and the Red Sox had not won a World Series since 1918. I wince sometimes at how
much the world has shifted, and realize that these memories that I hold dear
belong now to a bygone era, a time and place that so firmly belong to the Past.
But my own memory is not the only difficulty I am forced to
consider, but also the difficulty of writing about a single person, and a
singular personality. Indeed, I’m
writing about several people, but my concern is focused on one. I’m not worried
about Sam Bellamy.
I am Michael McCarthy’s only biographer.
We were not brothers, but we were bound by the blood of
ancestry, and we were born less than a year apart from one another. We grew up like brothers, though we had two
different sets of parents, constantly in each other’s company and constantly
enjoying every minute of it. When I
think back to our childhood together, I remember adventures wandering through
the woods near my house, or the cornfield near his house, or recounting parts
of our favorite movies, which included Goonies
and Stand By Me.
I should point out I don’t always talk this way. Just when I start feeling nostalgic.
One event stands out in my mind. It was a summer day when we were about ten or
eleven, and we were at the beach, climbing over the rocks around the tide pools
at one end of the beach, a part of the beach commonly referred to as Crabtown. We’d been
climbing these rocks since we were old enough to climb rocks, catching fish and
looking for crabs and clams. This day,
we were doing nothing much more exciting than throwing rocks, trying to hit an
outcrop some fifty feet out on the water.
Mike turned to me and said, “Do want to see a pirate ship?”
Coming from anyone else, this question might have been
surprising, ever ridiculous, but from Mike, my immediate reaction was sheer
anticipation. “Let’s go!”
We climbed along the rocks for about half an hour, out
farther than we ever had before, far away from the sandy beach where our
mothers were sitting under an umbrella laughing and gossiping. Along the way, Mike told his story.
“I was out here last week and was climbing along here, and I
found a cave just up there. It was low
tide, so I went inside, and you wouldn’t believe it! It was a ship, not huge, and not much left of
it, just like a skeleton of wood, but it was a ship. And the mast was still standing, and on top
of the mast was a pirate flag. I’ll bet
there’s treasure in there, too, but I didn’t look. Probably booby trapped.”
I nodded along with every beat of this story. Of course it was a pirate ship! Of course there was treasure nearby! Of course it was booby trapped!
So we walked along the rocks, until we reached the point
where the rocks stopped. Sure enough, it
was a cave of sorts, though a narrow cave, thirty or so feet high but at most
ten feet wide. Perhaps only six or seven
feet. Perhaps no more than two or three. It was years ago, and my memory may
exaggerate its width. The water flowed
into the cave, or crevice, which is a most accurate description, and Mike
explained, “Last time I was here, it was low tide, and you could walk right
it. We’ll have to come back some other
time. But I’m telling you, I saw a
pirate ship, and I think, up on the deck, I think I saw a skeleton. With a patch over one eye. And a wooden leg.”
We walked back toward the beach, over the rocks and past the
tide pools. I knew there was no pirate
ship. But that didn’t seem to
matter. What mattered was the sense of
adventure, the sense that next time, the tide will be out, we’ll be able to go
inside, and we’ll see something amazing!
Because that was what I wanted to believe. And that was what Mike made me believe.
Of course, we were just kids climbing some rocks at the
beach back then. But as I remember that
day, it seems now that it was the beginning of an interest that grew into
obsession. As I mentioned, Mike loved
adventure and loved the movies. Whether
sitting with our legs up on the seatbacks in front of us at the downtown Newport movie theater,
dubbed the Opera House for reasons that totally escaped our younger selves, or
laying on the floor of Mike’s living room watching a movie on VHS tape, movies
were a driving passion, and Mike always seemed to take the adventurers from the
big screen and try to push them even farther into our own lives, as he wove his
ridiculous, but wholly believable stories.
And somewhere between One-Eyed Willy and Indiana Jones,
Mike’s imagination ran head-long into the history of our town.
“Did you know that Newport used to be the pirate capital of
the world?” he shouted at me after school one afternoon. “There were pirates everywhere! Eventually, they got so sick of it that they
hung a bunch of them out on Goat Island.
And get this: They left them there as a warning to other pirates!”
Then, a week or so later, “Thomas Tew came from
Newport. He was one of the most feared
pirates of his day.”
And then, he found his favorite story: “Sam Bellamy, they
called him Black Sam, but I don’t think that was racist back then, he was from
Cape Cod. But his quartermaster, that’s,
like, second-in-command, his name was Paulsgrave Williams, because they had weird names back then. I think he probably was Paul to his friends, and he was from
Newport. They sailed all down the East
Coast, stealing treasure and sometimes stealing whole ships. Eventually, they split up, because Bellamy
wanted to visit his girlfriend. Williams
came to Newport to hide some of his treasure.
A storm hit that night, and Bellamy’s ship sunk. Williams went back to the Caribbean and swore
he’d never return to claim his treasure.
He said it was cursed!”
And that was it.
There was buried pirate treasure right here on Aquidneck Island. And it was cursed. I think it may have been this last facet of
the story that really captured his attention.
This was, after all, not long after the 1986 World Series, when we young
Red Sox fans were finally introduced to the Curse of the Bambino.
Any true, dyed-in-the-wool Red Sox fan reading this doesn’t
need me to explain it. But here’s the
gist: in 1918, the Boston Red Sox, then considered probably the greatest team
in the major leagues, traded a young pitcher to the New York Yankees named Babe
Ruth. You might have heard of him. Well, the Yankees took Ruth off the mound,
and he started knocking every ball out of the park, drawing huge crowds and
leading the Yankees to numerous World Series victories. And, supposedly, he cursed the Boston Red Sox
to never win a World Series again. And
ever since 1918, they hadn’t. Every time
they came close, the ghost of the Babe seemed to step in and make some wildly
improbable event happen that went against the Sox. It happened again in 1986, against the New
York Mets, when the Sox were one out away from victory until an error on a
ground ball up the first base line allowed the Mets to win. It seemed like just bad luck, but then we were
told, “Read about ’67. Or ’49. This isn’t the first time. It’s not bad luck, it’s the curse.”
I remember Mike even trying to break the curse, performing
weird rituals he completely invented, though he said they were, “totally real,
ancient secret rituals!” He’d chant
nonsense words over his Red Sox souvenir bat, or burn the complete set of the
’86 Mets baseball cards like a voodoo sacrifice. He was determined that he, and he alone,
could finally bring the curse to an end.
So curses were very much on his mind when he first came
across the story of Paulsgrave Williams and his cursed pirate treasure.
Mike’s research into the life of Williams and Bellamy was
thorough and impressive, especially since I was much more of the bookworm than
him. And while normally he wouldn’t have
any interest in an afternoon reading at the library, when he was determined to
find some fact or examine some book, he could talk his way into any rare book
collection or any otherwise off-limits archive like a con man fleecing his
mark. It was truly a beautiful thing to
witness, watching Mike flex his charm like a weight-lifter flexing a
bicep.
Years past on, and high school took our minds off other
pursuits, and girls took our minds off of high school. And for Mike, his time was additionally taken
up by (depending on the time of year) football, basketball, or baseball. As I said, I was the bookworm. But summertime, that was still devoted to Red
Sox and pirate treasure. And if every ancient
book, every locked archive led to another dead end, those summer days of exploring
the beaches, rocks and coves of Aquidneck Island were adventures enough by
themselves.
A decade after he first discovered the name of Black Sam
Bellamy, we were both out of college and just settling into our lives of being
twenty-something slackers.
It must have been in August when Mike called me. It could have been July, or maybe September,
but the best I can remember, I want to say it was August.
August is the very worst month to live in Rhode Island,
excepting perhaps February. New England
summer is beautiful, especially along the coast, when the breeze comes in off
the ocean, full of salt in the air and the faint smell of seaweed that reminds
you of the waves crashing just a few miles away; the breeze keeps the worst of
the summer heat at bay. And come
September, and fall, New England transforms into a blazing carnival of
colors. And in between is August, one of
those months when New England makes a sincere attempt to convince you to live
anywhere else. The sun blazes down, the
tourists line up on bridges crossing into Newport, and all the moisture that refuses to fall in the form of rain hangs in the air
like a blanket.
As the old timers say, “It’s not the heat, it’s the
humidity.”
I must confess, I’ve never ever heard an old timer say,
“It’s not the heat, it’s the humidity.”
I’ve heard plenty of middle-age jabbering morons say it, always preceded
by “as the old timers say…” But even
if the old timers are full of it, it is the humidity that kills you, especially
in August, when its feels like your breathing under water, and not even the sunset brings any respite.
And I think it was during one of those New England heat
waves, the summer of 2000, the world having just survived into the new
Millennium and caught up in election year politics and who would be voted off Survivor, that Mike called. I remember the conversation clearly,
especially my end of it, which consisted mostly of sounding bewildered and
saying, “What?” over and over again.
“Dave! You wanna come
find a skeleton with me?” he said in his loud, exuberant voice, the kind of
voice that makes you want to say yes even if you have no idea what he’s talking
about, which I didn’t.
“What?” I said.
“I think I found it!”
“What?” I repeated, trying to sound less confused and more
conversational. And failing.
“The burial spot of Paulsgrave Williams!” His enthusiasm was more infectious than any
cold, and I could feel it pulling me in.
But I couldn’t help thinking this sounded more like a fever dream than a reasonable conversation.
“What?” I said one more time. Then, for clarity, “Where?”
Mike didn’t rise to that bait. “Come with me. Tonight.
We’ll check it out.”
“Why do we need to find a skeleton at night?” I
asked. “Isn’t daytime a much better time
for finding skeletons?”
“C’mon! We have to do
this!” And for just a second, I knew,
just knew he was right. We had
to do this. To go out in the middle of
the night, to God knew where, to unearth a human skeleton. And then, just as quickly, sanity reintroduced
itself, and the feeling passed. Mike’s
enthusiasm was indeed infectious, but I’d spent twenty-some years building up
antibodies.
We’d both gone to college in Massachusetts, instead of Rhode
Island. Stonehill for Mike, Clark
University in Worcester for me. Mike had
gone back home after college, and now had an apartment in Newport. I’d been there a couple times. I’d gone back home as well, but my parents
were mid-divorce at that point and I decided to move back to Worcester and find
an apartment there. An hour and a half
of driving separated us, and I wasn’t about to make that drive for a wild goose
chase for some pirate’s old bones.
I tried to get that point across to him.
He was insistent.
“There’s a skeleton in Touro Park!
Under the Tower!”
I knew exactly what he was talking about. The Newport Tower, sometimes called the Old
Mill Tower, sometimes the Viking Tower, was an icon of Newport. Suddenly, I understood why he wanted to go at
night. What he was planning was the kind
of thing that got you arrested.
“Don’t do it,” I told him.
“You’ll just get yourself into trouble.
There’s nothing there.”
Mike took the rejection in stride. Which is a nice way of saying that, several hours later, we were skulking around Touro Park, pacing off various numbers of steps in various directions from the Tower, looking for something that Mike swore he'd know when he found it. Somehow, acting totally suspicious in the middle of this park in downtown Newport (holding shovels, in case I forgot to mention that, because Mike said we'd have to dig to find these bones), we managed to not see a single police officer. We kept this up until after midnight, until the Newport bars disgorged their drunks, but found nothing. Mike said he'd be back the next night. I yawned my approbation and drove groggily home.
A few more years past.
Mike never mentioned a skeleton or Touro Park again. But Mike, I felt sure, stuck with treasure
hunting, though he talked about it less and less on the increasingly rare times
when we spoke, mostly over the phone.
Until September,
2004, when the phone rang at 5 o’clock in the morning.
In case it’s never happened to you, there is never a good
reason for the phone to ring at 5 o’clock in the morning. It only means bad things. On the other end was Rose, Mike’s girlfriend,
whom I had met exactly once.
“Wha-huh?” I said, my words still thick with sleep.
“Have you heard?” she said, not the least bit sleepy.
“Heard what?”
“I guess not. Listen,
last night, at the Patriots game, there was an accident. Mike…he didn’t make it.”
Feeling myself getting dumber by the second, as I refused to
let reality into this pre-dawn world, all I could utter was, “Didn’t make what?
The funeral was held a few days later, a picture-perfect New
England September day. The skies were
clear of all but the lightest clouds, the leaves not yet turned, as we walked
in solemn procession bearing the casket of my best friend. You’ll excuse me if I stop my description
there. I don’t do well with funerals,
lens of time be damned.
I went back to my apartment in Worcester, to the job I
didn’t much like, to my mundane life and daydreams about writing the next
amazing American screenplay, which would of course be filmed by the next
Spielberg, and tried to pretend everything was normal. But it wasn’t, and wouldn’t be, couldn’t be,
ever again.
And I thought about Mike, about growing up, about his
stories, his adventures, his tall tales.
I thought how nothing he ever told me turned out to be true, but somehow
that never mattered, and I was always ready to believe. I never felt cheated by his stories; I always
felt better for having gone on his adventures, and now, I missed them. But time would go one, the Red Sox were going
to be in the playoffs, and he’d like that.
And I could imagine him walking up to the ghost of Babe Ruth and saying,
“Seriously, what the actual Hell is going on here?” And if there was a pirate treasure somewhere
buried under Newport, which I knew, deep down, there wasn’t, it would stay
buried for a while longer. And that was
as it should be. I was, essentially,
backing myself into a proverbial corner, curling up into a metaphorical ball,
and sulking.
My bout of self-pity last for two weeks, until the first of
October, when I got the letter.
It was, at first glance, an ordinary letter. I opened the envelope without much thought,
pulled out the single piece of paper, unfolded it, and read it. A strange, unearthly sensation came over me,
like cold air blowing against the back of my neck, only this was happening to
my entire body all at once.
I looked at the envelope; read the return address. It seemed to have been mailed by an M. McCarthy, from Newport, Rhode Island.
I only knew one M. McCarthy from Newport, Rhode Island.
I looked again at the paper the envelope had contained. It was two lines. Just two.
And with those two lines, my whole life changed.
41 degrees 29.356
minutes
71 degrees 19.231
minutes
(That's it, the whole first chapter. Hope you liked it. Thanks for reading it.)